Lightyear Customer Reviews, & Expert Test

Is Lightyear good for investing?

Lightyear is a simple and approachable way to invest in stocks and ETFs without unnecessarily large fees. A very well-designed low-cost investing app with discounted FX charges, limit and recurring orders for investing in local and international markets.

Special Offer: Sign up with a promo code GOODMONEYGUIDE deposit at least £50 and get 10 trades for free. T&Cs apply. Capital at risk.

Fees: Lightyear is very cheap for investing, there is no account fee for a general investing account and only £1 commission for buying UK shares and a max of $1 for US stocks. Lightyear make their money on the FX Fees. With Lightyear, they apply the FX fee on top of the interbank rate, so you can actually see the amount you are charged for the conversion.

When I interviewed Martin Sokk he told me Lightyear aims to expand into different countries quickly, so they can help people to invest in their local stock markets, but also in America, which is where a large percentage of people want to buy stocks.

And rightly so, US shares are all household names, and one of the key drivers for investing is to buy companies you love and use. Lightyear will make money charging 0.1% per trade  (or $1 what ever is bigger) and converting GBP, HUF & Euros, etc. into USD when people buy US stocks.

They charge, 0.35%, which is higher than Interactive Brokers’ 0.02% but much lower than the 0.5% charged by AJ Bell, Saxo Markets and IG, or the 1% from Hargreaves Lansdown and Interactive Investor.

FX, therefore, is a key part of Lightyear’s monetisation strategy because, if you charge very low commission and account fees you have to make money somehow. So Lightyear, aim to make it’s money in the background, initially from foreign exchange fees. FX is a very good way to make money, because, a) no-one really understands how the pricing works, and b) because you don’t see the charge, it’s built into the buy/sell spread.

You can see in the below example what the fees would be when I bought some Tesla shares testing the app.

Market Access: Lightyear has just added 1,300 new instruments, bringing the total up to almost 5,500. These include well-known UK names such as Rolls-Royce, easyJet and IAG; to defense ETFs, US stocks. This is great becuase one of my concerns about new investing apps is that they normally just cater to the most heavily traded apps. It’s great to see Lightyear providing wider market access.

Plus, they are proactive about it too. Lightyear says they have put live 98% of non-complex US instruments asked for by customers in the past 3 months.

One of the other really cool things about Lightyear is that you can listen to earnings calls directly on the app.

Multicurrency account & order types

Another point to make here is that you also get a multi-currency account, where you can hold foreign currency. The advantage of this is that you don’t need to do as many FX conversions which can help keep costs down.

Related guide: Compare FX rates for buying US stocks from the UK.

Lightyear comes with features like fractional US shares, limit orders, and regular investing. You can also quickly see which shares pay the highest dividends or make the most money relative to their share price to help you pick stocks.

Progression to servicing local customers and local markets

When Lightyear first started, you could only invest in a handful of UK stocks, and they were ADRs listed in the US denominated in USD, rather than the local listings on the LSE. So, you were paying an FX fee when you really shouldn’t have to, admittedly, there is no stamp duty so technically paying 0.35% on FX rather than 0.5% to HMRC is cheaper.

Lighyear have a cash and investment ISA, but no SIPP account, but I suspect that is next on the “product roadmap”.

But anyway, they’ve sorted that now, and if you want to invest in UK shares like Lloyds, you can actually buy them on the LSE, something that eToro is yet to do.  With them, you still have to buy USD-denominated shares.

I’ve mentioned how annoying that is many times and yet they continue serve themselves as a global broker instead of their customers as locals. It’s nice to see that Lightyear, fixed that problem early on.

Like Transferwise, like Lightyear

To draw on one final Transferwise comparison, it is very easy to use app-as-a-tool to help you start investing as cheaply as possible. The thing is though is that, transferring money is like car insurance. No-one really has any loyalty to their insurer, they just do it and move on. Investing is different. Investing is not like insurance, when you open an investing account, you could be using it for the next 30 years.

I think there will always be a place for traditional investment platforms because they provide excellent customer service and brand loyalty, they are mature platforms for mature investors and fees will eventually come down, as they have done in the past. Same as with Simpsons Tavern, it may not be as good for you as veganism, but if it survives, people will continue to go because they like it.

But, if low-cost investing apps are a gateway to getting more people to invest for their future, then they are the future too and will hopefully mature along with their customers, and Lightyear, in particular, is a great place to get started.