Investing with a stockbroker in the South African stock market can be an excellent way to grow your wealth, but finding the right account is crucial to your success. South Africa offers a range of stockbrokers catering to different needs, from beginner investors to experienced traders. This guide outlines what you need to know about South African stockbrokers, including how they operate, who regulates them, and what to look for when choosing one.
| Name | Logo | GMG Rating | Customer Reviews | Account Fees | Dealing Commission | CTA | Feature | Expand |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 |
GMG Rating |
Customer Reviews |
Account Fees $0 |
Dealing Commission 0.05% |
See Offer Capital at risk |
Features:
|
Interactive Brokers General Investment Account Review: Excellent low-cost investing and trading Account: Interactive Brokers General Investment Account Description: Interactive Brokers’ (IBKR's) GIA is aimed at sophisticated investors, and offers access to derivatives, options, and futures. The platform is one of the cheapest across all asset classes. Capital is at risk. Is IBKR's GIA a Good Account? IBKR’s GIA is its “universal account” that lets you invest in all asset classes via shares, CFDs, futures, options or funds. The account is excellent for sophisticated investors who want to manage their own portfolios with complex order types. It’s ideal for active investors who need access to a wider range of investment products like derivatives, options, and futures. IBKR is also one of the cheapest investment platforms across all asset classes, as it was built on offering electronic discount brokerage. Fees There is no account charge for general investment accounts at IBKR. When you buy and sell shares minimum dealing commissions are £1 in the UK or 0.05% of the deal size. Special Offers IBKR clients can earn $200 for each qualified referral while giving their friend the opportunity to earn up to $1000 of IBKR stock. What is IBKR’s Platform Like to Use? The investment platform is a slimmed-down version of its exceptional desktop trader station. For investing it gives you a good overview of shares and funds.
Pros
Cons
Overall5 |
|
 |
GMG Rating |
Customer Reviews |
Account Fees $0 |
Dealing Commission £0 |
See Offer Capital at risk |
Features:
|
eToro's GIA lets you invest in US stocks with zero dealing and account feesAccount: eToro General Investment Account Description: eToro’s GIA lets you invest in a huge range of US, UK & global shares & ETFs with no account fees. It also has a thriving community of investors you can follow, and you can copy their investments with eToro's CopyTrader tool. Plus, there are some mainstream professionally managed portfolios to buy. eToro is a multi-asset investment platform. The value of your investments may go up or down. Your capital is at risk. Is eToro good for long term investing? eToro is a great GIA for investing in the long term if you’re interested in buying major US stocks and copying the portfolios of other successful traders. Jeppe Kirk Bonde, for instance, has historically produced market-beating returns for his 30,000 followers, and now has over $100m copying his portfolio (though past performance is no indication of future results). (Disclaimer: eToro is a multi-asset investment platform. The value of your investments may go up or down. Your capital is at risk.). Pricing: No account fees or commission – great value and a low minimum account size of £10 Market Access: Access to the most popular global markets through a general investment account. There is limited access to smaller cap shares, but you can invest in crypto, which most other traditional investing accounts don’t let you do. Plus the copy trading feature lets you see what other investors hold in their portfolios and what they think about the,m which you can copy manually or automatically. App & Platform: really easy to use, no complex order types but that’s not really what eToro is about it’s about discovery. Customer Service: Quick responses from the live chat and email support and if you’re accuont is over $30k you get a personal account manager. Research & Analysis: eToro have some really good social channels with educational vides, some excellent “how to” courses (which are free so no need to buy a trading course from a Youtuber. But the most unique thing is the social feed where investors chat about what they are investing in. However, there are some things I believe eToro could improve for long-term investors from the UK. The main issue is that the accounts are in USD, and you can’t invest through tax-free wrappers, or into a pension, and there’s limited access to bonds and funds. eToro also used to absorb the stamp duty on UK shares. But now you have to pay the 0.5% UK stamp duty tax when investing in UK companies, so that tax break has gone. I explain below why these are issues if you’re investing in the long term. USD Account Balances With eToro, your account balance has to be in USD. This is part of how it makes money (when it converts your GBP into USD) but it means that if you buy UK shares, then over time your profits can be eroded by differences in the GBP/USD exchange rate. Granted this can also work in your favour, but you’re not trading FX – you’re investing. And if the exchange rate moves 5% and you have a £100,000 portfolio, that’s £5,000 lost. No ISA or SIPP With an ISA you can invest up to £20,000 a year and no pay tax on the profits. Unfortunately, eToro doesn’t have its own ISA. It does have a co-branded eToro ISA in partnership with Moneyfarm. But Moneyfarm is more of a digital-wealth manager, so you may as well just open a separate account with Moneyfarm – it will at least help you resist the temptation to speculate with your long-term investments. With a SIPP, you’re investing for your pension and, as with an ISA, you don’t pay tax on your profits. But with eToro you can’t invest in a SIPP, so if you’re buying shares and aim to hold them until you retire, your tax bill at the end of it could be unnecessarily high. No Funds, Corporate Bonds or Small-Caps eToro is great at giving investors access to popular markets like US stocks, cryptocurrency and commodities, but its market access is pretty limited. You can’t invest in small-cap growth stocks in the UK, for example. And if you’re building a long-term portfolio, it should be diverse so you should add in some corporate bonds (fixed-income investments) and some funds that spread the risk and invest in lots of shares and bonds for you. This is a shame, because eToro generally does give people what they want. However, it would be better if it focused a bit more on what people need. On the positive side, eToro does let you invest in bonds through bond ETFs or fixed-income portfolios like YieldGrowth which contains a range of 13 bonds from Vanguard, iShares and SPDR. What is eToro’s Platform Like to Use?
Pros
Cons
Overall4.6 |
How to choose a stock broker in South Africa?
Stockbrokers act as intermediaries between investors and the stock market. They execute buy and sell orders on your behalf and may also offer additional services such as research, portfolio management, and access to various financial instruments like shares, ETFs, and bonds. Depending on your needs, you can choose between:
- Full-Service Brokers: These brokers provide personalized advice, portfolio management, and access to research and analysis. They are best suited for investors who want hands-on guidance but come with higher fees.
- Discount Brokers: These brokers offer a more cost-effective solution, allowing you to trade independently through online platforms. They are ideal for self-directed investors who don’t require advisory services.
These Are The Key Features to Consider When Choosing a Stockbroker
- Regulation and Security: Ensure the broker is licensed by the FSCA. You can check if client funds are held in segregated accounts to protect your money in case the broker faces financial difficulties.
- Fees and Costs: Compare trading fees, monthly account fees, and any hidden charges. Also ,consider brokers with competitive pricing for your trading frequency (e.g., frequent trading vs. long-term investing) like Interactive Brokers and eToro.
- Trading Platform: Evaluate the broker’s online or mobile trading platform for ease of use, reliability, and available features like real-time data, charting tools, and order types.
- Investment Options: Check the range of financial instruments available, including stocks, ETFs, bonds, and derivatives. Look for brokers offering access to both the Johannesburg Stock Exchange (JSE) and global markets.
- Research and Education: Some brokers like Interactive Brokers provide in-depth market research, stock analysis, and educational resources. These tools can be invaluable, especially for beginner investors.
- Customer Support: Ensure the broker offers responsive and accessible customer support via email, phone, or live chat.
Is it safe to use a stockbroker in South Africa?
In South Africa, stockbrokers are regulated by the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA). The FSCA ensures that brokers operate transparently and adhere to strict financial standards to protect investors. When choosing a broker, always verify their FSCA registration to ensure they are legitimate and compliant with local regulations.
Costs of Using a Stockbroker
Stockbroking fees in South Africa can vary widely. Typical costs include:
- Trading Fees: Charged per transaction, often as a percentage of the trade value (e.g., 0.25% – 0.5%).
- Monthly Account Fees: Some brokers charge a fixed fee for maintaining your account.
- Platform Fees: For using advanced trading platforms, particularly with full-service brokers.
Stock Trading Tips for Beginners in South Africa
- Start Small: Begin with a small investment to familiarize yourself with the platform and market dynamics.
- Educate Yourself: Take advantage of educational resources provided by your broker, such as webinars and tutorials.
- Diversify Your Portfolio: Spread your investments across different sectors and asset classes to reduce risk.
- Monitor Fees: Keep track of the fees you are paying and assess whether they align with the value you are receiving.
South Africa’s stockbrokers offer a wide range of options for investors with varying levels of experience and financial goals. By choosing a broker that aligns with your needs, you can effectively access the stock market and build a portfolio that meets your objectives. Whether you opt for a low-cost platform like EasyEquities or a full-service broker like PSG Wealth, ensure they are regulated, cost-effective, and provide the tools and support necessary for your investment journey.